Type 4 or Type 2 Guarding: SICK S30A Light Curtain Response Time, SICK S30B Scanner Resolution, and FX3 Safety Relay Outputs
Type 4 or Type 2 Guarding: SICK S30A Light Curtain Response Time, SICK S30B Scanner Resolution, and FX3 Safety Relay Outputs
Selecting a safety light curtain, laser scanner, or safety relay is not simply a matter of matching device types on a datasheet. The required guarding performance must come first, followed by the complete safety chain and its installation geometry. A sensor with a strong capability cannot compensate for an inadequately rated input module, while a fast curtain cannot eliminate the need to account for relay delay, machine stopping time, and possible reach-over, reach-under, or reach-around access. This guide explains how Type 4 and Type 2 devices differ, why resolution and beam count are separate parameters, and how catalogue response times combine into the separation required around a machine.
The Risk Assessment Decides the Class, Not the Brand
A machine risk assessment must establish the required performance level before any order code is selected. That requirement determines the safety architecture, diagnostic coverage, external monitoring, and installation arrangement. Only after those functional requirements are known does it make sense to choose a particular light curtain, scanner, relay, amplifier, or input module. Buying first and justifying the selection afterward reverses the design process and can leave a nominally capable device protecting an inadequately rated function.
Type 4 and Type 2 are device classes within the same IEC 61496 family for guarding with optoelectronic protective devices. They are not interchangeable labels for different manufacturers or product families. A PL d laser scanner is not a lower-cost way to create a PL e point-of-operation guard. The achievable level of the complete safety function is limited by its weakest channel: a self-monitoring Type 4 curtain connected to an inadequately rated input does not retain the advantage that made it Type 4.
Our listings illustrate the distinction:
- The SICK S30A-4111CP Type 4 safety light curtain is listed with SIL 3 and PL e capability.
- The SICK S30B-2011CA safety laser scanner is listed with SIL 2 and PL d capability.
- The SICK FX3-CPU000000 safety relay is listed with SIL 3 and PL e capability.
These are listing statements, not substitutes for the complete manufacturer documentation. The risk assessment must still consider the machine, reset arrangement, contacts, wiring, application, and applicable installation requirements.
Type 4 Self-Monitoring Against a Type 2 Test Interval
A Type 4 device continuously tests its transmission and receiver chain. When it detects a fault, it forces the safe state rather than continuing to imply that the protected area is being monitored. This continuous diagnostic approach is particularly important where an undetected failure could conceal a person at the point of operation. The additional monitoring capability is not cosmetic: it changes how a fault in the optical chain is managed.
A Type 2 device detects relevant faults within a test interval rather than continuously. That approach can be appropriate where the risk assessment requires a lower performance level or where separate monitoring addresses the relevant failure modes. The decision therefore depends on the required protection, not on a preference for the newest or most highly classified catalogue item.
The S30B scanner is suited to applications where configurable protective fields are more useful than one fixed vertical boundary. These include access areas and work-zone boundaries where entry into a defined region triggers machine stopping. Its listing names EN 61496, IEC 61508 SIL 2, EN ISO 13849-1 PL d, and EN 60825-1; the laser-product requirement named there governs the emitted beam as well as its relationship to the stopping function.
The S30A is a fixed protective-field light curtain with a different fault-detection concept. A risk assessment must establish whether continuous self-monitoring is necessary, whether the scanner’s configurable fields address the actual access route, and whether the downstream chain can support the selected device class.
Resolution, Field Height and Beam Count Are Three Different Numbers
Resolution describes the smallest object that can interrupt the protective field. Our listings give 14 mm resolution for the S30A and 30 mm object resolution for the S30B. On that basis, the S30A is the relevant choice when the risk assessment calls for detection of fingers or small parts, while the S30B is a body-and-limb device intended for larger detected objects. Resolution must be matched to the hazard, the part of the body that can approach it, and the required performance level.
Protective field height describes the covered vertical extent. It is quoted as 300 mm for the S30A. By contrast, the SICK C4M-EE0213A1AA0 listing states 14 beams but provides no protective field height. Beam count is a construction detail rather than a substitute for field height. Although the numbers are related through beam pitch, pitch is not the same figure as resolution. Without the height and pitch, the C4M’s coverage cannot be derived from its beam count.
This distinction prevents a common ordering error. Selecting a curtain by beam count or housing length instead of by protective field height can produce a device that covers the wrong part of the access opening. The installation drawing, not a catalogue family name, should define the required coverage.
Range must also be checked. Our S30A listing quotes 0.5 to 10 m, so its transmitter and receiver must be at least half a metre apart; that pair is unsuitable for a very short infeed span. The C4M is listed with a detection range of 0 to 10 m, but its application still requires confirmation of object detection performance and mounting conditions from the manufacturer data sheet.
Response Time Adds Up Through the Whole Chain
Response time is a property of the signal path, not a complete measure of machine stopping time. Our listings state 15 ms for the S30A, under 15 ms for the C4M, under 15 ms for the FX3-CPU000000, and under 30 ms for the FX3-XT1084002. The SICK UE410-4RO3 is listed with a response time of 20 ms or less. The switching amplifier and any contactor or final output stage can add further delay.
Consequently, a curtain with a 15 ms response feeding a relay with a 15 ms response does not provide a 15 ms safety chain. The engineering calculation must combine the sensor response, safety logic response, and final switching-device delay with the machine’s measured stopping time. The worst case supported by the documentation should be used, rather than relying only on the fastest printed figure.
Choosing the slower FX3-XT1084002 is not automatically incorrect. Its extra delay simply has to appear in the safety-distance calculation. The final contactor’s opening time is particularly easy to overlook because it occurs after the safety relay has issued its stop request. Every timing value in the calculation should come from the appropriate component documentation, and machine stopping time must be measured on the actual machine.
Working Out the Safety Distance
For an optical guard, separation must account for movement during the total interval between interruption and removal of dangerous motion, plus an addition addressing possible reach past, under, or around the protective field. A useful method is:
s = K × Ts + C
Here, s is separation in millimetres, K is the assumed approach speed in millimetres per second, Ts is the total time from interruption to removal of dangerous motion in seconds, and C is the applicable addition in millimetres. The value of C depends on resolution and mounting geometry; it must be taken from the applicable standard rather than guessed.
Consider an example using an assumed approach speed of 2000 mm/s. A 15 ms curtain and a 15 ms relay produce a 30 ms stop-signal interval. The travel term is 2000 × 0.030 = 60 mm. If the geometry prevents reaching past the field and the applicable addition is 100 mm, the example separation is 160 mm. If a person could stand between the curtain and the hazard and the addition is 850 mm, the same chain gives 910 mm.
Now replace the relay with the FX3-XT1084002. Its listed response time is under 30 ms, so the example signal interval becomes 45 ms. The travel term is then 2000 × 0.045 = 90 mm. With the 100 mm addition, the example separation grows from 160 mm to 190 mm.
These examples cover only the signal path shown in the arithmetic. The machine’s own stopping time must also be measured and included in the total Ts used for the final design. Two lessons follow. The C addition dominates these examples, making mounting geometry more consequential than a few milliseconds of signal delay. Also, catalogue timings cannot substitute for measurement of the connected machine’s hazardous motion.
Outputs, Muting and the Question of Restart
The S30B listing specifies two OSSD safety outputs. These semiconductor outputs are intended to be monitored so that a stuck-on fault can be detected by the downstream safety device. Cross-fault detection between output lines also contributes to a Category 4 architecture. Outputs therefore cannot be treated as ordinary machine outputs: the monitoring device must be rated for the required safety level. Guidance on Schneider limit switch selection and wiring illustrates why device identity, contact arrangement, and wiring method must be checked together.
The FX3-CPU000000 offers four NO or NC channels with dual-channel inputs, while the FX3-XT1084002 provides four relay-output channels with screw terminals. The SICK UE403-A0930 is described in our listing as a SIL 3 Category 4 safety switching amplifier with a muting function for M4000 light curtains. Muting temporarily suspends protective operation for a controlled material flow. It should be initiated by independent logic, such as two sensors combined with a timed or directional sequence, and announced by a lamp. It must never provide an uncontrolled route for a person to pass.
Restart and external device monitoring are configuration decisions with safety consequences. The UE410-4RO3 is listed with manual and automatic reset options. Automatic restart is defensible only where no person can be in the hazard; a monitored start or guard contact must establish that the guard is closed. This topic also depends on proper channel assignment and diagnostics, as discussed in Industrial I/O module configuration.
Environment and provenance remain important. The UE410 is listed at IP20 and -25 C to +55 C, so it belongs in a cabinet rather than the machine environment. The C4M and S30B are listed at IP65. The KEYENCE PJ-V90 controller is offered as a used unit that our listing says should be inspected and functionally validated before reuse. The pre-owned Leuze 50116467 MK348 connection unit is listed at IP65 and for compatibility with Leuze M 4000 components. Our catalogue also carries an M4000 designation for a SICK accessory: family names never prove cross-manufacturer compatibility. Match the full order code and wiring diagram.
| Device | What our listing states (type, resolution, response, level) | Where it belongs in the guard design | What you must still confirm |
|---|---|---|---|
| SICK S30A-4111CP | Type 4 light curtain; 14 mm resolution; 15 ms response; SIL 3 and PL e | Fixed point-of-operation guarding | 300 mm field height, 0.5 to 10 m range, 24 V DC, M12 connection, and whether IP protection is required |
| SICK S30B-2011CA | Type 2 laser scanner; 30 mm object resolution; SIL 2 and PL d | Configurable access or work-zone protection | Range of approximately 4 m, up to 56 fields, two OSSD outputs, environmental suitability, and complete safety requirements |
| SICK FX3-CPU000000 | Safety relay; response under 15 ms; SIL 3 and PL e | Downstream dual-channel safety logic | Four NO or NC channels, 24 V DC, machine stopping time, wiring, and reset arrangement |
| Leuze 50116467 MK348 | Connection unit; type, resolution, response, and safety level not stated | Interface for compatible Leuze M 4000 components | Full compatibility, electrical details, condition of the pre-owned unit, and the relevant manufacturer documentation |
Frequently Asked Questions
Is a Type 2 scanner always adequate because it can provide more protective fields?
No. Configurable fields improve coverage flexibility, but they do not replace the performance level required by the risk assessment. A scanner marked PL d in our listing is not automatically suitable for a function requiring PL e.
Does a light curtain response time determine the complete stopping distance?
No. The calculation must include sensor response, relay and amplifier delay, contactor operating time, and measured machine stopping time. The final safety distance also depends on the applicable addition for resolution and mounting geometry.
Can beam count be used to calculate protective field height?
Not reliably. Beam count alone does not provide the pitch or stated field height. For the C4M-EE0213A1AA0, our listing provides 14 beams but no protective field height, so the manufacturer data sheet and installation drawing are required.
What is the difference between OSSD outputs and relay outputs?
OSSD outputs are monitored semiconductor safety outputs designed to support fault detection. Relay outputs mechanically switch contacts, so the contact arrangement, wiring, and downstream device must also be assessed for the required safety architecture.
Does muting allow an operator to enter the hazardous area?
No. Muting temporarily suspends the protective function for a defined process event. Independent initiation logic, clear status indication, restricted timing, and safe sequencing are required; muting is not a personnel bypass.
Selecting guarding equipment begins with the risk assessment, not the product family. The sensor class, resolution, field geometry, timing chain, outputs, reset method, environment, and downstream monitoring must all support one coherent safety function.
Our team can cross-reference the exact part number and current lead time, then flag any details that still require confirmation from the manufacturer data sheet or wiring documentation.